According to The Globe and Mail:
”Goldfish can solve problems that dolphins can't. When a goldfish jumps out of its bowl, it's thinking past its immediate environment. Dolphins don't have the cognitive leap,” Mr. Manger [from Johannesburg's University of the Witwatersrand] said in a telephone interview Thursday.Is this for real?
”Dolphins can do some things, but they have to be trained to do them. That's more of a reflection of low-intelligence.”
1. How does Mr. Manger know what is going through a goldfish's mind?
2. Actually, when a goldfish jumps out of its bowl, do we need Mr. Manger to imagine what it is thinking
3. If a goldfish is so smart, why is he jumping out of the bowl to begin with?
4. If training is a sign of low-intelligence, what should we make of Mr. Manger's university degree?
But then there is Dr. Lance Barrett-Lennard.
Wading into the debate Thursday, Dr. Barrett said the highly social networks of dolphins indicated they had strong social intelligence.Hmmmm.
"A dolphin could have a brain the size of a walnut and it wouldn't affect the observations they live very complex and social lives," Dr. Barrett-Lennard said. "They keep account of who their friends are, with very complicated hierarchies and allegiances. The other thing is they have spatial maps. They know exactly where to go when they need to look for certain food."
Dolphins have a strong social intelligence, know who their friends are, have complicated hierarchies and allegiances, and have well developed spatial maps for finding things [like missile launchers?].
Goldfish have a tendency to jump out of their fishbowls, losing what they have gained in a single moment of carelessness.
How about this:
Men are from Mars.
Women are from Venus.
Israelis are dolphins.
Palestinians are goldfish.
OK, so maybe dolphins are better than Israelis at knowing who their real friends are.
Technorati Tag: Israel.
4 comments:
"Dolphins can do some things, but they have to be trained to do them."
I am not sure dolphin will be the critter I have in mind for the comparison. We are more like a giraffe - the pain in our backside is very slow in reaching the brain ;-)
Interesting analogy.
How many goldfish have saved human beings - and how many dolphins?
My problem with the article is the line:
When a goldfish jumps out of its bowl, it's thinking past its immediate environment.
First I assumed he was talking about what the fish is thinking after it jumped out as it realized it could not breathe.
Now I realize he means that the goldfish jumps because it realizes there is something outside of the bowl.
So the goldfish is bright because it thinks outside the bowl--and kills itself in the process.
I suppose that makes lemmings absolute geniuses.
Post a Comment