Tuesday, July 24, 2007

MISSIONARIES ON TISHA B'AV: A bad combination. When I came home after Kinos, I saw a handful of them coming out of the house next door--and they saw me. The man in the lead came over, smiling, and offered me a pamphlet.

Normally, I just try to match them--smile for smile--but the incongruity of the situation bugged me.

I asked him if he knew what today was.
Naturally, he didn't--no reason why he should.
I explained to him about Tisha B'Av, about what happened on that day throughout history: including the Crusades and the Jews slaughtered by the Crusaders on the way to recapture Jerusalem.

His response: Well, that's your opinion.

I told him, no...it's historical fact.

His response: That's your opinion.

Rather than lose my temper, I went inside...where I thought about all the come-backs I could have said. For instance, I could have responded that some of his beliefs were based on opinion.

My favorite response would have been the 'Muslim' response, something filled with outrage like this:
What? Jews were killed during the Crusades and you say that is merely an opinion? Six million Jews were slaughtered by the Nazis--and you're telling me that is only an opinion too?! How dare you desecrate the memories of Jews who have been murdered...
Of course I would have been twisting his words, making a scene, and possibly intimidating him and the rest of his group, but it does seem to work.

Technorati Tag: and .

1 comment:

  1. B"H I go back and forth on how to respond. I recently wrote about a personal experience. As you know Yad leAchim has a branch in the US now. Along with R' Tovia Singer and Jews for Judaism, they may opps. to volunteer, suggest for how to handle things, or a contact in order to report these kinds of activities.

    ReplyDelete

Comments on Daled Amos are not moderated, but if they are exceedingly long, abusive, or are carbon copies that appear over half the blogosphere, they will be removed.