 |  |
You don't see the resemblance?
Read on.
Wednesday, September 28, 2011
Daniel Pipes: Is Turkey Going Rogue?
This article is from Daniel Pipes' website and also appeared on The National Review
It is reposted here with permission
by Daniel Pipes
National Review Online
September 27, 2011
But, in reality, Turkey may be, along with Iran, the most dangerous state of the region. Count the reasons:
It is reposted here with permission
Is Turkey Going Rogue?
by Daniel Pipes
National Review Online
September 27, 2011
In a Middle East wracked by coups d'état and civil insurrections, the Republic of Turkey credibly offers itself as a model thanks to its impressive economic growth, democratic system, political control of the military, and secular order.
 Recep Tayyip Erdoğan effectively bought the June 2011 elections by pumping credit into the Turkish economy. |
Ahmadinejad and Erdogan Take On The US and Russia?
When Erdogan ticked off Russia, you could argue that it was just a stupid mistake:
Russia has sent two nuclear-powered submarines to patrol Eastern Mediterranean waters around Cyprus and enforce the island's right to explore for undersea oil and gas in its territorial seas, according to information from Defencenet.gr (Greece), citing a Russian Foreign Ministry spokesman.But Ahmadinejad is going out of his way to thumb his nose at the US:
Alexander Lukashevich said that Russia supports Cyprus and guarantees its security if it is threatened.
The Russian move is being interpreted as a clear warning to Turkey to stay away from Noble Energy's drilling sites.
Mideast Media Sampler 09/28/2011
From DG:
1) Fool me once shame on you; fool me twice, cause I've been listening to Thomas Friedman
First a parable: Once an inquisitive student sought out Rabbi Tom "Hillel" Friedman and asked Rabbi "Hillel," "Please teach me about the Middle East while I stand on one foot." The wise sage stroked his mustache, smiled thinly and said, "It's always Israel's fault. All the rest is commentary. Now go and study." Thomas Friedman's detachment from reason is in full display in his latest column, 2 for 2 or 2 for 1? First he makes some valid observations:
If clashes erupt between Israelis and Palestinians today, there is no President Hosni Mubarak of Egypt to absorb the flames. Now there is a Turkish prime minister, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, ready to fan them — toward Israel.But then, a few sentences later writes:
Video: Rosh Hashana Greetings From Latma
I didn't realize Latma made videos before Rosh Hashana.
But they do.
And here it is:
But they do.
And here it is:
Remember When Wikileaks Was A Big Deal?
If you provide people sufficient background information, they are capable of behaving correctly and making the right decisions
Inside WikiLeaks: My Time with Julian Assange at the World's Most Dangerous Website, by Daniel Domscheit-Berg, former Wikileaks spokesman
Alasdair Roberts has an interesting article on Wikileaks in The Wilson Quarterly.
There was a time that Wikileaks seemed to be a force to be reckoned with:
WikiLeaks’ boosters said that the group was waging a war on secrecy, and by the end of 2010 it seemed to be winning. The leaks marked “the end of secrecy in the old-fashioned, Cold War–era sense,” claimed Guardian journalists David Leigh and Luke Harding. A Norwegian politician nominated WikiLeaks for the Nobel Peace Prize, saying that it had helped “redraw the map of information freedom.” “Like him or not,” wrote a Time magazine journalist in December, WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange had “the power to impose his judgment of what should or shouldn’t be secret.”The logic seemed so simple--and so irrefutable.
Once people read the leaked information, they would become enraged and demand reform.
Barry Rubin: Letter from Bratislava, Slovakia: Two States for Two Peoples
By Barry Rubin
A Czech friend, who has achieved considerable success in life since then, reminded me that for several years he was a window-washer under the Communist regime. The government of the proletariat believed that the worst thing it could do to people who had dissented was to send them into the proletariat. During that period, he was very active in the democratic opposition.
Since he spoke good English, he was often asked by his comrades (probably not the right word) in the anti-Communist struggle for freedom to be the guide for visiting Western sympathizers. Often, he recounts, these were Western leftists eager to explain to those Czechs engaged in the battle for liberty that Marxian socialism was really a great idea, they just needed to make a few adjustments.
Imagine if you will, people who had grown up in an ideological dictatorship that sent people to prison for making the wrong joke being lectured by a bunch of spoiled, well-dressed Western intellectuals on the splendor of their prison.
From YU: Rosh Hashana To-Go 5772 and Past Years
Rosh Hashanah To-Go 5772
Tuesday, September 27, 2011
Al Jazeera Bureau Chief Admits To Conspiring With Hamas
...in the summer of 2008 Al Jazeera threw a welcome-home party on live TV for Samir Kuntar after the Lebanese national was released from an Israeli prison where he had served twenty-nine years for bashing in the head of a four-year -old girl.
The Strong Horse, by Lee Smith, p. 30
The Israeli Prime Minister's Office has issued a statement about the confession of Al Jazeera bureau chief Samer Farik Muhammad Allawi of conspiring with Hamas.
Conviction Of Al Jazeera Afghanistan Bureau Chief Allawi
Allawi was convicted, according to his own confession, of conspiracy on behalf of the Hamas terror organization.
Samer Farik Muhammad Allawi, born in 1966, from Sebastia, who resides in Pakistan and serves as Al Jazeera's Afghanistan bureau chief, was arrested on 9 August 2011 at the Allenby Crossing, on suspicion of involvement in Hamas activities.
During his investigation by the Israel Security Agency, Allawi admitted that was recruited in 1993, while in Pakistan, to Hamas. Until 2004, he served there as a member of the "Supreme Palestine Committee", which supervises and directs Hamas institutions. He also collected donations for Hamas-affiliated organizations such as "Al-Aqsa Association" and the "Palestinian Information and Media Center."
Raymond Ibrahim On The Difference Between Muslims And Islamists
Raymond Ibrahim writes about what happens When Muslims Are More 'Radical' than 'Islamists'.
Ibrahim writes in the context of a televised debate between a traditional Muslim and an Islamist--where Ibrahim defines Islamism as:
Ibrahim writes in the context of a televised debate between a traditional Muslim and an Islamist--where Ibrahim defines Islamism as:
a hybrid abomination of sorts, whereby the better principles of Western civilization are absorbed and rearticulated within a distinctly Muslim paradigm. For instance, the Western stress on human freedom, human dignity, and universal justice, is, for Islamists, transformed into a stress on Muslim freedom, Muslim dignity, and Muslim justice—all, naturally, at the sake of the infidel.
Moshe Bogey Ya'alon: The False Palestinian Narrative (A Refutation)
From Moshe Bogey Ya'alon's column in today's Israel Hayom
The False Palestinian Narrative
The Palestinians have succeeded in making us believe a series of false assumptions, and on the basis of these false assumptions, they have submitted a series of false claims. Our problem with them is not where the borders will be, but rather with their refusal to recognize that this is the Jewish national home.
Public discourse in Israel about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict over the past several months, particularly in light of the meeting of the U.N. General Assembly and the Palestinians’ intention to ask for recognition as a state has been full of erroneous perceptions that need to be eradicated. This is necessary not only because these perceptions mislead many Israelis and cause confusion, but also because that same confusion radiates outward, leading many international leaders in the West to adopt them.
The source of these perceptions is the false Palestinian narrative. Precisely because this is happening, it is important to state that there is nothing more just than the Jewish people’s right to return to live in their ancestral homeland. This is moral, historical, legal, political, security-related, national and religious justice.
On the other hand, the false perceptions have been presented very well in Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas' various speeches over the years, and recently with even greater force. This is the place to refute them.
1. According to the first perception, the conflict between Israel and the Palestinians is territorial in essence, and its solution is well known and could be accomplished in a short time if both sides would only show a great deal more flexibility.
Arlene Kushner On Netanyahu And Abbas Leading Up To Rosh HaShannah
From Arlene Kushner:
September 27, 2011
"A New Year Approaches"
This is most likely the last posting before Rosh Hashana begins tomorrow night. And so here I extend my wishes for a year of blessings and peace to everyone.
Dip your apple in the honey: Take the time to know life's sweetness.
~~~~~~~~~~
As for Klal Yisrael (the Community of Israel), my prayer is that we will stand together during these hard times, protected from Above.
~~~~~~~~~~
Last week, I spoke about the marvelous counter-conference -- "Perils of Global Intolerance at the UN" -- held in a hotel across the street from the UN while Durban III was going on. Sponsored by the Hudson Institute and Touro College, under the dedicated and vigorous guidance of Anne Bayefsky of Eye on the UN, the conference hosted a magnificent series of participants.
Book: Mourning Under Glass--Dealing With Terror And Loss After The Merkaz HaRav Massacre
On March 6, 2008 an Arab terrorist went on a murderous rampage in Jerusalem's Merkaz HaRav Yeshivah. Eight young men were killed. Among them, my beloved sixteen-year-old son, Avraham David Moses, hy"d. This book explores the aftermath of terror and loss while grappling with the tensions between memory and memorial.
Dr. Naftali Moses, describing his book Mourning Under Glass
Here is an excerpt from Mourning Under Glass:
And cursed be he who says: Revenge!
Revenge like this, revenge for the blood of a small child
Even the devil has not created…
Haim Nahman Bialik “On the Slaughter”
Chapter One: The Darkest Night
Revisiting An Example Of Palestinian Fauxtography
This Fan Page DOES NOT belong to any Religion. We are not here to insult other Religion. The main aim of this PAGE is to spread the Truth about what is happening in Palestine to all the Human Beings.
Freedom Will Come To Palestine, from their Facebook page
If the goal were actually to tell the truth, then this group has obviously failed miserably.
This particular fraud was already uncovered back in June, but it bears repeating:
Mideast Media Sampler 09/27/2011
From DG:
1) Ellison elides I won't critique every aspect of Rep. Keith Ellison's op-ed Support the Palestinian Bid for Statehood, but two points he makes caught my eye.
And in this case, Arab countries that have never recognized Israel would implicitly be doing so when they voted to recognize a Palestinian state that envisioned itself beside Israel in a two-state solution to their conflict. That in itself would be a breakthrough, confirming Israel’s solid standing in the region.This is hopelessly convoluted.
Video: Tutu Says Israel Has The Right To Exist
Israel is like Hitler and apartheid
The Honorable Archbishop Desmond Tutu
Here is a video of Desmond Tutu with the group What Is Rael.
Desmond Tutu said during a meeting with them that boycotting Israel is wrong and said that Israel has the right to exist as "independent sovereign state, who's boundaries are secured and recognized".
Here is the video:
Monday, September 26, 2011
Does YOUR Freedom Of Speech Entitle You To Deprive A Pro-Israel Speaker Of THEIRS?
No, it doesn't.
Not even if you are preventing a pro-Israel speaker from speaking.
Not surprisingly, the 10 Muslim students who shouted down Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren and prevented him from speaking think they did a great thing.
Until the 10 Muslim students were found guilty of disrupting Michael Oren's speech:
Not even if you are preventing a pro-Israel speaker from speaking.
Not surprisingly, the 10 Muslim students who shouted down Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren and prevented him from speaking think they did a great thing.
Until the 10 Muslim students were found guilty of disrupting Michael Oren's speech:
In an emotional conclusion to a case that generated national debate over free speech rights, a jury on Friday found 10 Muslim students guilty of disrupting a speech by Israeli Ambassador Michael Oren at UC Irvine last year.
Can You Just Imagine A "Palestine State" Joining The International Criminal Court?
If not--you're not the only one.
Prof. Sabel: Palestinian State Would Not Join International Criminal Court To Avoid Exposing Palestinians To Prosecution
Prof. Sabel: Palestinian State Would Not Join International Criminal Court To Avoid Exposing Palestinians To Prosecution
Hebrew University International Law Professor Robbie Sabel (Former Legal Adviser Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs) On Israel Radio Middle East Magazine 25 September 2011
Question: Would Palestinian state join the International Criminal Court?
US May Not Even Need To Use Its Veto To Oppose Palestinian State
After all is said and done, the US may be off the hook and not need to use its veto, as the Security begins to privately consider Abbas's request for recognition of a Palestinian state:
The Palestinians' initiative to seek U.N. recognition as a state, which goes to the Security Council on Monday, faces an uphill struggle to secure the nine votes needed for approval.
Without those votes in the 15-member body, the United States will be spared the embarrassment of having to veto the application, which would be a further blow to its floundering efforts to secure Middle East peace.
The Iconoclast: The Theme Netanyahu Dropped Smack Into The Middle Of The U. N.
Brian of London has pointed out the most important part of Netanyahu's speech at the U.N.. It was the mention of "militant Islam" six times. One example is here:
"And these critics continue to press Israel to make far-reaching concessions without first assuring Israel’s security. They praise those who unwittingly feed the insatiable crocodile of militant Islam as bold statesmen. They cast as enemies of peace those of us who insist that we must first erect a sturdy barrier to keep the crocodile out, or at the very least jam an iron bar between its gaping jaws." [emphasis added]It was not all the talk about "peace" --
Ron Kampeas Denies Palestinian Plans For An Apartheid State--But When Challenged, Remains Silent (Updated)
The Palestine Liberation Organization's ambassador to the United States said Tuesday that any future Palestinian state it seeks with help from the United Nations and the United States should be free of Jews.
"After the experience of the last 44 years of military occupation and all the conflict and friction, I think it would be in the best interest of the two people to be separated," Maen Areikat, the PLO ambassador, said during a meeting with reporters sponsored by The Christian Science Monitor. He was responding to a question about the rights of minorities in a Palestine of the future.
PLO ambassador says Palestinian state should be free of Jews, USA Today, 9/18/11
After the expected outcry in response to Areikat's statement, the following was added to the article:
Clarification: In the headline and story, Palestinian Ambassador Maen Areikat says he was referring to Israelis, not Jews, when he stated that "it would be in the best interest of the two people to be separated first."Funny that no such clarification was ever needed last year when Areikat said Jews would be transfered out of a Palestinian state:
Israel Is Not Nearly As Isolated As Some Like To Claim
I'm unmoved by the hand-wringing over Israel's "isolation." When I came to the country 30 years ago, Israel had no relations with the USSR (and Eastern Europe), China, and India. There was no foreign investment and a UN General Assembly resolution still stood, condemning Zionism as racism. It will take more than a Cairo mob, a truculent Turk, and another UN resolution to make me feel "isolated."
Middle East expert Martin Kramer, quoted by Todd Warnick
It's always popular to claim that Israel is isolated:
We all know the "big lie" technique: you say something enough times and everyone begins to believe it, whether anything close to approximating the truth or not.
Nowhere is that perhaps more successful these days than in Palestinian politics: "Gaza is the most densely populated place on earth"; "there are 4 (5? 6?) million Palestinian refugees"; "the number of Palestinians between the Mediterranean and the Jordan is equal to the number of Jews", and so forth and so on. Palestinians and the Arab countries make statements and an ignorant - or hostile world - accepts them at face value.
The latest canard Israel is now facing - internally and externally - is the country's supposed "diplomatic isolation." AP writes: "Israel isolated ahead of UN vote"; "Israel's alliances looking frayed," says the LA Times; "Israel isolated," says this Russia Today TV report; and of course, Israel's internal media headlines, whether television or many of its newspapers, constantly scream out as to Israel's "isolation" on the world stage.
Mideast Media Sampler 09/26/2011
From DG:
1) An ad Thomas Friedman would support. Wouldn't he? Thomas Friedman is forever complaining about America's "addiction" to oil. It's a silly use of the term, though others (including President Bush) have adopted. A new ad promoting the recovery of oil from oil sands "vexes the Saudis."
I sure can see why. The New York Times reports:
What Is It About Palestinians And Donkeys?
Challah Hu Akbar has a post with pictures of the various Palestinian reactions to Obama's speech coming out in defense of Israel.
Here is one of them, where the Palestinian Arabs painted a donkey as a symbol of Israel:
Here is one of them, where the Palestinian Arabs painted a donkey as a symbol of Israel:
Barry Rubin: Letter from Prague: What The Betrayal of Czechoslovakia in 1938 Can Teach Us About The World and Israel Today
By Barry Rubin
“We have no interest in oppressing other people….It is not so much the country of Czechoslovakia; it is rather its leader, Edward Benes. He has led a reign of terror….The Czech maintenance of a tremendous military arsenal can only be regarded as a focus of danger. We have displayed a truly unexampled patience, but I am no longer willing to remain inactive while this madman ill-treats millions of human beings.” –Adolph Hitler, April 14th, 1939 (quote not fully authenticated, see note at end of my article)
Prague, Czech Republic
Visiting the Czech Republic prompts thoughts of the 1938 Munich agreement. Analogies with Nazism and the 1930s are overused today, made even more tasteless and cliché-ridden by the fact that many of those using them know very little about the situation then and now.
Beyond the simple narrative usually offered, a more detailed analysis shows a number of points that fit both situations better than people realize. That’s true despite the very important differences between the two cases.
Arlene Kushner On The UN Speeches Of Abbas And Netanyahu
From Arlene Kushner:
September 25, 2011
"And So?"
On Friday, Mahmoud Abbas, putative president of the PA, spoke at the UN General Assembly.
I won't belabor his words unduly. They were pretty much as we might have expected -- a justification of his intention to unilaterally pursue membership in the UN for a Palestinian state.
Sunday, September 25, 2011
Barry Rubin: To Those Always Wrong About the Middle East and Who Never Lose A Gram of Arrogance or A Moment of Sleep Over the Tragedies They Create
By Barry Rubin
On the occasion of your supporting Palestinian unilateral independence despite the dangers this presents for Israel while simultaneously criticizing Israel for not giving massive concessions in exchange for nothing. On the occasion of the world groveling before Mahmoud Abbas, a ruler of a mere one million people who is in partnership with an explicity genocidal terrorist group, is dependent on Western hand-out, refuses to negotiate or compromise, and has cancelled elections at a time when democracy is supposedly the big thing in the Middle East.
On the occasion of your ignoring the fact that Turkey is ruled by an Islamist party engaged in massive repression and the transformation of the country into a dictatorship, holding that regime up as a model for other Muslim-majority states as it arrests dissidents on a massive scale and keeps them under lock and key while threatening war with Israel. The U.S. government chooses this regime as its co-director in the most important new international counter-terrorist initiative and as its manager of the political transition in Syria.
Mideast Media Sampler 09/25/2011
From DG:
1) They just don't make facts like they used to Arthur Brisbane deals with a supposed conflict of interest between the New York Times bureau chief Ethan Bronner and a PR firm. (More background here.)
Mr. Bronner was pointed in arguing that the attack by Mr. Blumenthal, who writes critically of Israel’s dealings with the Palestinians, was ideologically motivated and designed to discredit Mr. Bronner. Mr. Blumenthal’s piece may well have been influenced by an animus toward Mr. Bronner’s reportage for The Times. But the fact remains that the Lone Star engagement created a problem and stands as a reminder that The Times must be fastidiously independent, in reality and in appearance, or face attacks like this one.In the end Brisbane's most damaging charge was that Bronner's actions constituted an "appearance of conflict of interest." I have sent a few e-mails to Brisbane about other issues.
Barry Rubin: Here and There in the Middle East: Sharia Law Measuring Scale, Turkey or Iran, and the Israeli Peace Initiative Contest
By Barry Rubin
1. One of my readers remarked that what we need to study now is the use of fifth columns to subvert and overthrow countries rather than the 1940-era conventional warfare blitzkrieg. Actually, and this was well-known at the time, the Germans used a very sophisticated strategy of ideological and institutional subversion. It is surprising how much this has been forgotten. Political parties and militias were set up or subsidized; newspapers bought up; German minorities organized. If any of you are interested in this I will provide examples in future, some of which I described (using U.S. intelligence archives) in my book, Istanbul Intrigues.
2. Turkey is now going to sell Egypt both unmanned aircraft and swift patrol boats. Not that there’s anything wrong with that, since both are U.S. clients and, according to the Obama Administration, allies. But this is something to watch in the future. Remember that the relatively moderate military commanders in both countries are on their way out and will be replaced by ideologically motivated (or opportunist) officers who will attack whatever they’re told. With excitable, reckless, and anti-American Recep Edrogan running Turkey and excitable, reckless, and anti-American Amr Moussa perhaps soon to be Egypt’s president, old American friends may soon be attacking other old American friends, or even U.S. forces.
Friday, September 23, 2011
Video: Latma's "Somebody To Hate"
Until the full English translation comes out, here is this week's song parody: Somebody to Hate:
The Issue Is Not Security; The Issue IsThat Israel's Rights To The Land Supersede The Palestinian's
Caroline Glick calls it.
Israel has fallen into the habit of defensively phrasing its rights--and requirements--in the context of security and defense in the face of the ongoing Palestinian terrorist attacks.
That may be seen by some as a way to avoid the hard issues in negotiating with the Arabs, but as history has clearly shown: the Palestinian Arabs have consistently avoided any real negotiations--the kind that require give as well as take, concession as well as demand--instead resorting to demands, threats, unilateral moves and terrorism.
Keep in mind that resorting to terrorism applies equally to Abbas and Fatah as it does to Hamas. The ongoing incitement of hatred against Israel by Abbas borders on, and may very well legally constitute, genocide.
In any case, as Glick points out, in constantly pursuing peace and accommodation with the Arabs, Israel has neglected that its claims to the land are superior to that of the Palestinian Arabs.
Israel has fallen into the habit of defensively phrasing its rights--and requirements--in the context of security and defense in the face of the ongoing Palestinian terrorist attacks.
That may be seen by some as a way to avoid the hard issues in negotiating with the Arabs, but as history has clearly shown: the Palestinian Arabs have consistently avoided any real negotiations--the kind that require give as well as take, concession as well as demand--instead resorting to demands, threats, unilateral moves and terrorism.
Keep in mind that resorting to terrorism applies equally to Abbas and Fatah as it does to Hamas. The ongoing incitement of hatred against Israel by Abbas borders on, and may very well legally constitute, genocide.
In any case, as Glick points out, in constantly pursuing peace and accommodation with the Arabs, Israel has neglected that its claims to the land are superior to that of the Palestinian Arabs.
Mideast Media Sampler 09/23/2011
From DG:
1) Revising history I have a trivia question before our regularly scheduled commentary: To whom did Bill Clinton reportedly say, "I'm a colossal failure, and you made me one...?" After Prime Minister Yitzchak Rabin was assassinated in November 1995, he was succeeded by Shimon Peres. Peres quickly after assuming the reins of power started a series of withdrawals from Palestinian cities. Two weeks into his term, Peres withdrew Israeli troops from Jenin. An Associated Press story from November 20, 1995 reported:
Thousands of jubilant Palestinians whistled and clapped as Yasser Arafat arrived by helicopter Sunday to honor the first West Bank city given autonomy under the latest Israeli-PLO agreement. ... Janin is the first of seven West Bank cities that Israeli troops are scheduled to pull out of by spring. The pace of the withdrawal was accelerated after the Nov. 4 assassination of Israeli Prime Minister Yitzhak Rabin. "The path of peace continues, and it will not be slowed by those who raise their guns or by assassinations," Arafat said.
Thursday, September 22, 2011
Barry Rubin: I Hate Israel! I Hate America! I’m a Muslim! I’ve Got it All! Let Me Be Your Leader!
By Barry Rubin
Scene: A nightclub in Morocco.
Abdul: “I’m sorry, sir, this is a private room.”
German official [from the Nazi-controlled DeutschBank]: “You dare not keep me out of here!”
Rick: “Your cash is good at the bar.”
German official: “What! Do you know who I am?”
Rick: ‘I do. You’re lucky the bar’s open to you.”
–“Casablanca,” (1942)
First it was Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini and the Iranian revolution.
Hey, he said in effect, Yes, I’m a Persian, Yes, I’m a Shia, but I hate Israel and want to destroy it! And besides we’re all Muslims. So let me lead the Middle East. I know the way to kick the Americans out of the Middle East, too. By force! And the blood spilled and behold, Iran was popular for a while. But the Arabs and Sunni eventually found other heroes, and some became frightened of Iran’s power.
Video: UN Walkout During Ahmadinejad Speech
CNN reports there was a Walkout at U.N. as Ahmadinejad speaks
Here is the video:
Delegations from the United States and several European nations walked out of the U.N. General Assembly Thursday during Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad's speech, in which he repeatedly condemned the United States and said some countries use the Holocaust as an "excuse to pay ransom... to Zionists."
Delegates from France, Germany, and the United Kingdom were among those who walked out. Delegations from Canada and Israel were not present from the beginning.
Here is the video:
Arlene Kushner On Making Sense Of What Happened At The UN
From Arlene Kushner
September 22, 2011
Well, I still cannot tell you exactly what's going to happen tomorrow, after Netanyahu and Abbas address the UN. But the focus has sharpened considerably. And I can certainly look at what's happened so far.
~~~~~~~~~~~
Yesterday, President Obama did two things of significance with regard to this whole drama.First, he met with Abbas, and told him that he indeed will veto the PA bid in the Security Council, if it comes to that.
I cannot tell you what Abbas said privately to Obama. But publicly the stance of the PA was defiant. They will go on, its representatives declared, and submit the request for full membership for a Palestinian state to the Security Council.
Will Sarkozy Now Allow Obama To Play Role Of Israel's Friend To The Hilt?
Yesterday, the UN was supposed to be the stage with Abbas as the star, playing out the drama towards the recognition of a Palestinian state.
But along the way, it looks like there may be another drama unfolding.
Sarkozy is making Obama look pro-Israel:
But along the way, it looks like there may be another drama unfolding.
Sarkozy is making Obama look pro-Israel:
A last-ditch U.S. effort to head off a Palestinian bid for U.N. membership faltered. President Barack Obama tried to qualify his own call, just a year ago, for a Palestinian state. And French President Nicolas Sarkozy stepped forcefully into the void, with a proposal that pointedly repudiated Obama’s approach.
Photo: "Psssst Mahmoud, This Is Your Conscience Talking!"
 |
| "Oy, why couldn't it have been Arafat or at least Jiminy Cricket!?" |
Hat tip: My Right Word
Technorati Tag: Abbas.
Mideast Media Sampler 09/22/2011
From DG:
1) NYT ? Erdogan; Bibi not so much
Of Recp Erdogan and Binyamin Netanyahu, which one has a) been carrying out mass arrests of the military and of journalists b) been allying himself with Islamists c) been rewriting the constitution to make it easier for his party to stay in power and d) had his military violate international borders to fight terrorists? Let's go the opinion pages of the New York Times for some clues. There's an op-ed by Carlos Strenger Netanyahu's friends, Democracy's enemies.
Wednesday, September 21, 2011
Anne Bayefsky: "Palestine" at the UN Sports Emblem with no Israel
| For Immediate Release: September 21, 2011Follow us on Facebook and Twitter. See our September 22 Conference web-site. | Contact: Anne Bayefsky anne@hudsonny.org (917) 488-1558 |
| This article by Anne Bayefsky appears on The Weekly Standard. |
The logo of “the Permanent Observer Mission of Palestine to the United Nations” – on their website and on top of their official statements at the U.N. – shows the Palestinian Authority’s claim to a Palestine that stretches throughout the entire historical entity of the former Palestine mandate.  Absent from the logo is any hint that Palestine consists of anything other than Arab territory. No nod is given even to the U.N.’s 1948 decision to divide the region into Jewish and Arab sectors. |
Missing Peace: Is the UN going to make a fatal blunder in the Palestinian – Israeli conflict?
by Yochanan Visser and Sharon Shaked
The situation in the West-Bank seems to be relatively quiet and, except for an occasional brawl between Arabs and Jews in a hotspot or two, nothing seems to indicate an upcoming dramatic event. Thousands of miles away in New York, however, a real storm is gathering as the world has gone wild again about the Palestinian – Israeli conflict.
The feverish diplomatic activities that are taking place around the Palestinian request for UN membership resemble international reactions to a war.
Sadly, these last ditch efforts to renew the peace process are doomed.
Why? Because those attempts completely ignore a strategic decision made by the PA almost three years ago.
After the election of Bibi Netanyahu as prime minister of Israel, the PA decided to implement the decision. It abandoned the peace process and instead decided to pursue international recognition of a unilateral declared Palestinian state.
This decision not only constituted a breach of the Oslo accords but also meant the end of the protracted peace process that had existed since 1993.
Consistency
Since then, all decisions and acts of the PA have been consistent with what has been agreed upon since the introduction of the revised strategy. One example was the refusal of the PA to negotiate during the unilateral building stop in the West-Bank which was announced by Israel in 2009.
The international community, however, ignored the PA decision and increased pressure on Israel instead.
Arlene Kushner On The UN Vote On Recognizing A Palestinian State
From Arlene Kushner:
September 21, 2011"Imminent Now?"
A quick housekeeping update: After my last post, my gmail address went out again briefly, and then was again reinstated by GMail. Hope it won't happen again, but keep utilizing akushner@netvision.net.il when writing to me. As I expect to post frequently in the next few days, keep in mind that if you fail to receive my material it might pay to check my website:
~~~~~~~~~~
The various projected doings at the UN are, perhaps, almost upon us. But here I want to provide some significant background regarding the issues surrounding a Palestinian Arab state.Earlier this week, I attended a conference sponsored by the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs and the World Jewish Congress on the subject of "The Rights of Israel as the Nation-State of the Jewish People in International Diplomacy."Participants (in no particular order) included:
- Ambassador Dore Gold, who heads the JCPA
- Minister for Security Affairs Moshe Ya'alon
- Dan Diker, Secretary-General of the World Jewish Congress
- Professor Ruth Lapidoth, Professor Emeritus of International Law, Hebrew University
- Ambassador Alan Baker, former legal adviser to the Israel Ministry of Foreign Affairs
- Advocate Irit Kohn, President of the International Association of Jewish lawyers and Jurists
- Professor Nicholas Rostow, Distinguished Research Professor, US National Defense University
There was overlap in the various presentations, certainly -- as well as consideration of topics I've touched on many times here. I will summarize by subject matter, noting sources as relevant, and limiting myself to the more significant facts and insights. There is considerable value to the material offered here.
Video From The Republican Jewish Coalition: Jews Speak Out Against Obama
Here is the text from the YouTube page:
Listen to real Jewish voters express their frustration with the Obama Administration.Here is the video:
We've heard the pundits, the pollsters, and the political scientists talk about the special election in NY's 9th congressional district. Now listen instead to real Jewish voters in New York talking about their frustrations with the direction of the Obama administration on Israel, the economy, and other issues.
This is especially important now, as the Obama Administration's pressure on Israel contributed to the Palestinian Authority's decision to abandon direct negotiations with Israel and instead push for statehood at the United Nations.
The voices of Jewish voters in NY-9 will multiply across the country and become an unmistakeable roar in November 2012, given the Administration's handling of Israel and the economy.
Poster: #Palestinian Authority To Palestinian Refugees: Get Lost!
Below is the latest poster from Elder of Ziyon: "We don't want you in Palestine", based on the following from Lebanon's Daily Star: Interview: Refugees will not be citizens of new state:
Palestinian refugees will not become citizens of a new Palestinian state, according to Palestine’s ambassador to Lebanon.Here is the poster:
From behind a desk topped by a miniature model of Palestine’s hoped-for blue United Nations chair, Ambassador Abdullah Abdullah spoke to The Daily Star Wednesday about Palestine’s upcoming bid for U.N. statehood.
The ambassador unequivocally says that Palestinian refugees would not become citizens of the sought for U.N.-recognized Palestinian state, an issue that has been much discussed. “They are Palestinians, that’s their identity,” he says. “But … they are not automatically citizens.”
This would not only apply to refugees in countries such as Lebanon, Egypt, Syria and Jordan or the other 132 countries where Abdullah says Palestinians reside. Abdullah said that “even Palestinian refugees who are living in [refugee camps] inside the [Palestinian] state, they are still refugees. They will not be considered citizens.”
Senator Menendez: Abbas Actions Would Force Re-evaluation of US Funding to Palestinian Authority
Please see links at end of post
UNITED STATES SENATOR ROBERT MENENDEZFOR IMMEDIATE RELEASESeptember 20, 2011
CONTACT:Menendez Press Office (202) 224-4744
Washington – At a press conference today with Senate Foreign Relations Committee members Chris Coons (D-DE) and Johnny Isakson (R-GA), Senator Robert Menendez, Chairman of the Subcommittee on the Western Hemisphere, said that if President Abbas moves forward with his plan to seek a UN resolution, “I will be obliged to re-examine all US funding provided to his government.”
“Let me be clear, the United States is not simply an ally of the Israeli people, it’s an ally of Israel’s democratic ideals,” said Menendez. “It’s an ally of its history, of its aspirations for peace and prosperity, its can-do spirit and amazing resilience in the face of threats from all sides.”
He added: “If President Abbas insists on acting irresponsibly this week in New York, he will make clear that he does not value America’s support and assistance to the Palestinian people and that Israel does not have a serious partner in the peace process.”
Anne Bayefsky: Iran Will Participate in Durban III
| For Immediate Release: September 20, 2011Follow us on Facebook and Twitter. See our September 22 Conference web-site. | Contact: Anne Bayefsky anne@hudsonny.org (917) 488-1558 |
| This article by Anne Bayefsky appears on The Weekly Standard. |
| The Iranian minister of foreign affairs, Ali Akbar Salehi, is now scheduled to take part in the conference known as Durban III, according to a well-placed source close to the United Nations. On September 22, the U.N. will "commemorate" the 10th anniversary of Durban I that ended just three days before 9/11. Given that Iranian leaders hope for the genocidal destruction of the U.N. member state of Israel and deny the Holocaust, their enthusiasm for the Durban phenomena blows the lid of the event's "anti-racism" cover. The 2001 Durban Declaration claimed Palestinians were "victims" of Israeli racism. Israel was the only one of 192 U.N. member states standing accused. Quite deliberately, therefore, Salehi will address one of the "roundtable" gatherings organized by the U.N., titled, "Victims of racism, racial discrimination, xenophobia and related intolerance: recognition, justice and development." |
Mideast Media Sampler 09/21/2011
From DG:
1) People problem
An article in the Atlantic argues that President Obama has a people problem, not a Jewish problem.
The storyline is older than the modern state of Israel. Reporters portray American Jews as parochially fixated on Israel and ask: Will the issue help Republicans win support from the rare affluent group that votes Democratic?The Lid argues that since Jews are disproportionately Democratic, the drop off Jewish support is more significant than that of other groups.
The answer is no. There's a round of these articles every presidential cycle, and the answer is the same every time. Obama will likely perform worse with Jews in 2012 than in 2008. But that's because he'll likely perform worse with nearly everyone.
One point that I think is misleading is this:
Barry Rubin: It’s A Bird (Actually a Turkey), It’s A Plane, It’s A Totally Wimpy U.S. Foreign Policy!
By Barry Rubin
Turkey’s Islamist regime subverted and then opposed sanctions against Iran. That regime also declared Iran and Syria, Hamas and Hizballah to be its friends. It also sponsored a terrorist group (the IHH) to provoke Israel into an international incident that would generate Islamist martyrs and dead Israeli soldiers. Now, rejecting Israeli conciliation attempts (regrets; donations to families of jihadists who got killed trying to kill Israelis), the Turkish regime escalated to the verge of war.
Now the Turkish prime minister goes to Egypt, proposes an alliance with the Egyptian revolution, then advocates a united bloc of Arabs, Iranians, and Turks as well as war on Israel to the assembled Arab foreign ministers.
Secretary of State Hillary Clinton tells the Islamist Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu, according to a U.S. diplomat,
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
Questions Raised About Palestinian Funds Missing Under Abbas's Watch
Challah Hu Akbar has put together sources indicating Abbas Lies About His Ties to the Palestine Investment Fund:
The other week Jonathan Schanzer wrote:
However, in recent years, Fayyad has been sidelined by PA President Mahmoud Abbas. Abbas has consolidated power, and he is now abusing it.
Separated At Birth: Julian Assange And Dr. Evil?
I saw a picture of Julian Assange of Wikileaks fame and one of...
Is there some resemblance?
U.S. Republicans Submit Resolution Supporting Israel's Right To Annex West Bank
The text of the Congressional bill follows--
U.S. Republicans submit resolution supporting Israel's right to annex West Bank
Rep. Joe Walsh (R-IL) introduces House resolution that supports annexation if the Palestinian Authority continues to push for UN vote.
U.S. Representative Joe Walsh (R-IL), introduced on Monday a resolution (with 30 co-sponsors) to support Israel’s right to annex the West Bank in the event that the Palestinian Authority continues to push for vote at the United Nations.
Barry Rubin: The Key Theme? Not Israeli Panic or Isolation But Western Unreliability
This post by Barry Rubin is reposted with permission
"Then was the palm of the hand sent from before Him, and this writing was inscribed: MENE MENE, TEKEL UPHARSIN. This is the interpretation of the thing....Thou art weighed in the balances, and art found wanting."
--The Book of Daniel
By Barry Rubin
Agence France Press reports that the Palestinian bid for UN recognition of unilateral statehood is “causing diplomatic panic” in the United States and Israel.
While Israel is certainly concerned, I think “panic” is totally wrong as a description. After all, Israel’s overwhelming interpretation is that the UN event will change nothing. As for U.S. panic, where has the Obama Administration been for the last year when this outcome was totally predictable?
The Associated Press says that Israel is “increasingly isolated” ahead of the vote. I don’t think that’s how Israelis look at this either.
Video: Debunking the Palestine Lie
I came across a new video about the history of the Israel-Palestinian conflict thanks to Ed Morrissey at HotAir:
...Encounter Books has just released a new Broadside titled A Century of Palestinian Rejectionism and Jew Hatred by Sol Stern. The book reviews the long history of the disputed territory, from the Ottoman Empire to today. Bill Whittle of Declaration Entertainment produced a longish video to accompany the book’s release, using the whiteboard animation technique to walk through the various attempts to get the Palestinians to accept a partition and a sovereign state. It’s a must-watch primer on the various issues under debate this week, as well as an indictment of current American policy:
Preventing Shariah Law From Infringing Upon The US Constitution
The issue of the implementation of Shariah law in Western democracies is a growing issue in general and is now beginning to be addressed here in the US as well.
For that reason, I thought this press release was interesting in that it addresses the issues involved in properly and legally preventing the infringement of Shariah Law upon the US Constitution.
For that reason, I thought this press release was interesting in that it addresses the issues involved in properly and legally preventing the infringement of Shariah Law upon the US Constitution.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
For more information and to schedule an interview, contact:Stephen M. Gelé, American Public Policy Alliance
www.publicpolicyalliance.org
admin@publicpolicyalliance.org or (800) 968-4211
‘American Laws for American Courts’ Superior to Oklahoma’s Amendment Banning Shariah Law
Washington, DC, September 19th, 2011- On Election Day 2010, Oklahoma voters overwhelmingly approved State Question 755 (the “Save Our State Amendment”) that would prevent “foreign laws in general, and Islamic Sharia law in particular, from overriding state or U.S. laws.” While the concerns of the voters were well founded in regards to the increasing use of foreign legal rulings into state court decisions (see Shariahinamericancourts.com), the tool used to combat it was imprecise and vulnerable to Constitutional challenges.The American Public Policy Alliance—promoters of “American Laws for American Courts” (ALAC) legislation passed in three states—responded to new challenges on Oklahoma’s State Question 755 by stressing the differences between the two approaches. ALAC is a facially neutral bill which seeks to ban foreign law from entering American courts when it infringes upon the Constitution.An article from the Center for Security Policy’s Christopher Holton in the American Thinker describes these differences.
Iran Is Viewed As The Top Threat--To The US
For Immediate Release
Contact: Eron Shosteck
Phone: 571-230-7300
Email: PRESS@SECUREAMERICANOW.ORG
September 19, 2011
You can download the Topline from the survey here.
You can download the cross tabs here.
NEW YORK, NY – Iran is now seen as the top national security threat to the United States, according to the findings of a new bipartisan poll of 1,000 Americans released by the non-partisan grassroots public interest group Secure America Now, and 96 percent of Americans view national security as an important factor when deciding their vote for the next president. The national poll of 1,000 likely 2012 election voters was conducted in August by Democrat Pat Caddell and Republican John McLaughlin. It has a +/- accuracy level of 3.1 percent.
Mideast Media Sampler 09/20/2011
From DG:
1) Who fact checks the fact checkers? Glenn Kessler take issue with Gov. Perry Rick Perry’s newbie mistake on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. (Many thanks to Lynn for pointing this out.) In response to this answer given by Gov. Perry,
Question: Do you believe there should be a Palestinian state?“I certainly have some concerns. The first step in any peaceful negotiation for a two-state solution for the Palestinians is to recognize the right of Israel’s existence. They have to denounce terrorism in both word and deed. And they have to sit down and negotiate with Israel directly. Anything short of that is a non-starter in my opinion.”the Washington Post's Glenn Kessler "corrects" the governor. Kessler starts:
Perry’s statement had three parts: Palestinians must recognize Israel’s existence; they have to denounce terrorism; they have to negotiate with Israel directly. “Anything short of that is a non-starter in my opinion,” he declared. Perry is stuck in a time warp. He’s describing a situation that existed in the 1980s, not really today. (Some people might argue about some of that, but we will explain below.)I do believe there's a time warp, but not in the way Kessler means.
Sultan Knish On The PLO--The Perpetually Dying Terrorist Group
Sultan Knish writes about The End of Palestine--and the end of a terrorist group that has been postponed for far too long:
Only through the unforced errors of others has the PLO escaped irrelevance again and again--which brings us to Abbas's appearance before the UN this week.
Hat tip: Seraphic Secret
Technorati Tag: Israel and PLO and Middle East.
...From its founding, the PLO had always been a tool of larger movements in the Arab Muslim world. It began as a tool of Arab Socialism, and Pan-Arabism, the dream of a single Arab state encompassing the entire Arab world. An Arab socialist Caliphate. Even while agitating for the Palestinian cause, Shukairy went on promoting Pan-Arabism, in which there would be no independent Palestine. But then again an independent Palestine had never been the point.Read the whole thing.
By the 70's and 80's, the PLO had become a poisoned knife that cut the hands of its wielders. This is the common enough fate of those who create terrorist groups and imagine that they can control them. The PLO had managed to commit a number of terrorist atrocities in Israel, and Arafat, the 3rd successor to Shukairy, had become a household name. But it had achieved nothing except headlines.
In the seventies, the PLO attempted to seize control of part of Jordan, which after all had comprised the majority of the Palestine Mandate. But the PLO was brutally suppressed by the Jordanian regime of King Hussein, and was expelled from the country. It tried the same thing again in Beirut a few years later, trying to carve a "Second Palestine" out of Lebanon. It failed again, with horrifying results for the entire country.
By the late eighties, the PLO was done. Egypt had made a peace deal with Israel. Jordan had a tacit understanding with Israel under the table. Syria was the only Arab country bordering Israel that was still somewhat supportive of the PLO, but it had little use for the PLO as a terrorist organization inside Israel, because the PLO was Arab, and the Golan Heights which Syria hoped to conquer was Druze. Instead Syria was far more interested in using the PLO to spread chaos in Lebanon for its own purposes.
Only through the unforced errors of others has the PLO escaped irrelevance again and again--which brings us to Abbas's appearance before the UN this week.
Hat tip: Seraphic Secret
Technorati Tag: Israel and PLO and Middle East.