Wednesday, October 06, 2010

Declassified Documents From Yom Kippur War Show How Crippling It Is For Israel To Obsess Over World Opinion

The release of previously classified documents revealing the decision-making process at the time is provoking debate.

Among the revelations:

Six hours before the Egyptians started crossing the Suez canal, then-Prime Minister Golda Meir convened an urgent consultation. Chief of Staff David "Dado" Elazar supported an advance strike and a wide call-up of reserves, saying it would save many lives. Defense Minister Moshe Dayan objected. We can't afford it this time, he said; what would the world say? Meir agreed. An advance attack is appealing but this wasn't 1967; the world won't believe us, she reportedly said. Army intelligence was ambiguous, not convinced that Egypt and Syria really meant war, although they had everything in place. "They know they're going to lose," the intelligence chief said.[emphasis added]
Letting world opinion dictate Israeli security concerns was nearly disastrous then.
If anything, the problem has only gotten worse.

Technorati Tag: .

1 comment:

NormanF said...

And all of those Israeli figures were forced to resign or leave office over their failures.

Israel cannot afford to pay too much attention to world opinion. When it comes push to shove, the Jews will be alone as they always have been, when it is their existence that is on the line.