More Palestinians Are Killed Than Israelis--But Look Behind The Numbers

Bret Stephens gives a response to those who eagerly fault Israel's claim to being a victim by pointing out that more Palestinians than Israelis have been killed--as if, had the numbers been reversed, these very same people would be rushing to Israel's defense.

Stephens notes:

In May 2002, at the height of the so-called al-Aqsa Intifada, I reviewed Israeli and Palestinian casualty figures, sticking to Palestinian sources for Palestinian numbers and Israeli sources for Israeli ones. Much was then being made in the Western media of the fact that three times as many Palestinians as Israelis had been killed in the conflict – evidence, supposedly, that despite the suicide bombings, lynchings and roadside ambushes perpetrated daily against Israelis, Palestinians were the ones who really were getting it in the neck.

But drilling down into the data, something interesting turned up. At the time, 1,296 Palestinians had been killed by Israelis – of whom a grand total of 37, or 2.8%, were female. By contrast, of the 496 Israelis killed by Palestinians (including 138 soldiers and policemen), there were 126 female fatalities, or 25%.

To be female is a fairly reliable indicator of being a noncombatant. Females are also half the population. If Israel had been guilty of indiscriminate violence against Palestinians, the ratio of male-to-female fatalities would not have been 35-1.

We've gotten to the point where the world recoils from the injustice of the victim suffering less than the aggressor.

Technorati Tag: Israel.