Showing posts with label Tom Friedman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Tom Friedman. Show all posts

Thursday, December 19, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 12/18/13: Sloppy Media Ignores Fact Israeli "Occupation" Is Over

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

Why Israel’s Democracy is not Endangered by the Lack of Peace

Eugene Kontorovich
Eugene Kontorovich, professor of international law.
Credit: Legal Insurrection, Photo: mos225 / YouTube

Eugene Kontorovich wrote an important essay for Commentary, Israel, Palestine, and Democracy. Here are three critical paragraphs from the middle of the essay:

Monday, November 18, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 11/18/13: The Truth About The History of Lydda/Lod

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

Thomas Friedman: The Incredible Shrinking Columnist


Thomas Friedman
Readers should not be buying what Thomas Friedman is selling.
Credit: Legal Insurrection -- Photo: AspenInstitute / YouTube



The featured image of Thomas Friedman above comes from a talk he gave about many of the marvels of modern technology. At the beginning he says that you have “every bit of knowledge available to you” from Google. It’s a bit of an overstatement, but his point is essentially correct.

One particular effective use of Google is fact checking writers like Friedman, who make unsubstantiated claims. In Friedman’s case, it happens quite a bit. He has a habit of taking great sounding ideas and turning them into columns. But that doesn’t mean that he’s right. Often he leaves out critical information.

This week Friedman did this once again.

Monday, September 30, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 9/30/13: Media Doesn't Notice Rouhani Continues To Manipulate The West

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

Even if Rouhani is a nuclear moderate, he is not rolling back Iran’s war against the West

In his column yesterday, Hassan does Manhattan, Thomas Friedman wrote about Iran’s new President Hassan Rouhani:
1) He’s not here by accident. That is, this Iranian charm offensive is not because Rouhani, unlike his predecessor, went to charm school. Powerful domestic pressures have driven him here. 2) We are finally going to see a serious, face-to-face negotiation between top Iranian and American diplomats over Iran’s nuclear program. 3) I have no clue and would not dare predict whether these negotiations will lead to a peaceful resolution of the Iranian nuclear crisis. 4) The fact that we’re now going to see serious negotiations raises the stakes considerably. It means that if talks fail, President Obama will face a real choice between military action and permanent sanctions that could help turn Iran into a giant failed state. 5) Pray that option 2 succeeds.
While there are no doubt domestic considerations that drove Rouhani to appear conciliatory, there’s one reason that Friedman left out.

Monday, September 09, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 9/9/13: The Secret of John Kerry's "Success": He Relies on Thomas Friedman!

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

Friedman has made a career of being wrong.

John Kerry’s testimony last week before Congress does not give confidence in the wisdom of his understanding.

In response to a question about a Thomas Friedman column – in which Friedman wrote that all Assad needed was a really good talking to and not any physical attack – Secretary of State John Kerry stated that Thomas Friedman “… is most often correct…”



I am a long time Friedman aficionado, and Kerry’s assertiont is untrue. Friedman has made a career of being wrong.

I could spend the next weeks cataloging those mistakes. But I don’t have the time. Instead let me treat to you to five or six of his greatest hits, errr, I mean misses.

Sunday, August 18, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 8/16/13: Like Obama, The Media Also Has Focus Issues With Israel

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

Attention Deficit Peace Process Disorder

Last week Thomas Friedman wrote a paean to John Kerry's peacemaking, Daring to fail. In the middle of the article he presented the same sort of "concern" for Israel that Secretary of State Kerry did.
Let’s start with a small item in Britain’s Independent newspaper on July 24, which began: “He once sang, ‘You Gotta Get Outta This Place,’ but now Eric Burdon is not even turning up at all having deciding to withdraw from a planned concert in Israel. ... The Animals frontman, whose hits include ‘House of the Rising Sun,’ and ‘San Franciscan Nights,’ had been due to perform alongside local Israeli bands in Binyamina. ... However, in a statement, Mr. Burdon’s management, said: ‘We’ve been receiving mounting pressure, including numerous threatening e-mails, daily. ...’” Burdon was just the latest of a rising number of artists and intellectuals who have started boycotting Israel over the occupation issue.
First of all as even Friedman acknowledged, Burdon's cancellation was due to "threatening e-mails." This wasn't an example of protesting Israeli policies. Second of all the stated purpose of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions movement isn't co-existence; it's no Israel. In one paragraph, while professing his concern for Israel, Friedman accepted threats as an acceptable way to oppose Israeli policies and validated those seeking to destroy Israel as legitimate.

Oh, and Friedman didn't even bother to keep up with the news. Burdon, in the end, reversed himself, ignored the threats and played in Israel. In other words Friedman's argument was obsolete before his fingers hit the keyboard. Wasn't he paying attention?

Thursday, July 11, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 7/11/13: Is Obama's Program For Arming Syrian Rebels Helping Hezbollah Terrorists Instead?

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection


1) Where did Hezbollah get American arms

Last month Lee Smith attempted to clarify if the administration had sent army to the Syrian rebels as it said it would, or not. All he (or anyone) got was studied ambiguity:
In fact, it’s still not clear what the White House is doing. In a June 13 conference call with reporters ostensibly rolling out the new policy, deputy national security adviser for strategic communications Ben Rhodes failed to provide any details. Reporters asked several times what kind of aid the administration had in mind, and whether Obama was actually going to arm the rebels. “We’re just not going to be able to lay out an inventory of what exactly falls under the scope of that assistance,” said Rhodes. Last week, Obama himself addressed the Syria issue, without providing any more clarity than his point man for strategic communications. In an appearance on the Charlie Rose show, the commander in chief told his host, “I’ve said I’m ramping up support for both the political and military opposition. I’ve not specified exactly what we’re doing, and I won’t do so on this show.” Maybe someone in the White House is advising Obama that obfuscation and ambiguity make a president look presidential.

Sunday, July 07, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 7/05/13: The New York Times Debates Pros and Cons of Egypt's Coup

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

1) Debating the coup at the New York Times

Much of the editorial opinion and some of the reporting in the mainstream media has opposed the Egyptian military's forcible removal of Mohammed Morsi as President of Egypt. Actually, surprisingly, there's a debate about it on the opinion pages of the New York Times. It's surprising because the reporting of the New York Times has been skeptical of the Tamarod, the protest movement that sought Morsi's resignation. It's doubly surprising because the New York Times isn't usually known for offering a diversity of opinion.

Wednesday, June 12, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 6/12/13: Richard Falk -- The UN Watchdog Who Doesn't Like Being Watched

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

1) How can you tell the difference between a terrorist organization and a liberal democracy?

The title is a trick question. In international fora, the terrorist organization gets a lot more respect.
Last week the Ireland led the way to prevent the European Union from designating Hezbollah as a terrorist organization.
Ireland is reportedly blocking efforts inside the European Union to formally blacklist Hezbollah as a terror organization. Britain recently initiated procedures to add the Iran-backed terror group to the E.U. blacklist, after Bulgarian officials linked Hezbollah to the July 2012 Burgas bombing that killed six civilians and a Cypriot court convicted a confessed Hezbollah member on terrorism-related charges. The U.S. has repeatedly called upon the E.U. to follow its example and ban the group, which has established deep roots on the Continent.
Even as Hezbollah's reach is seen in South America and Syria the European Union refuses to sanction the terror group operating within its borders.

But when it comes to Israel, the world is more intent on preparing a final solution.

Wednesday, June 05, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 6/05/13: Review of Events Leading Up To Protests Against Erdogan in Turkey

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection


1) Talkin' Turkey

Claire Berlinski provides the recent background for the foment going on in Turkey:
Of late, almost every sector of the electorate has felt unease about one part or another of Erdogan’s agenda. Restrictive new alcohol legislation, rammed through parliament, as usual, with contempt for the minority opposition, has prompted outrage; the so-called peace process with the PKK, which no one understands, has caused great unease. Anxiety is growing as well, not only about press censorship, but also about the prosecution of those who insult government officials or “Islamic values” on social media.

Wednesday, May 08, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 5/08/13: The Media Makes Excuses For Islamist Terrorists

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

1) Guess the source

  1. In its efforts to stop amateur rockets from nagging the residents of some of its southern cities, Israel appears to have given new life to the fledging Islamic movement in Palestine. For two years, the Islamic Resistance Movement (known by its Arabic acronym, Hamas) has been losing support internally and externally. This wasn't the case in the days after the party came to power democratically in early 2006; despite being unjustly ostracized by the international community for its anti-Israeli stance, Hamas enjoyed the backing of Palestinians and other Arabs. Having won a decisive parliamentary majority on an anti-corruption platform promising change and reform, Hamas worked hard to govern better than had Fatah, its rival and predecessor.

Tuesday, May 07, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 5/07/13: Like a Laser -- New York Times: "Syria is not Iraq"

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

1) Bill Keller's truism

Former executive editor of the New York Times, Bill Keller states the obvious, "Syria is not Iraq." In short, Keller argues that he trusts President Obama's instincts. However since he offered a mea culpa for having once supported the Iraq war, his arguments leave some skeptics unconvinced.
Bill Keller apparently lacks a working irony detector, assures us “Syria Is Not Iraq” nytimes.com/2013/05/06/opi…
— Matt Yglesias (@mattyglesias) May 6, 2013
I wonder if @nytkeller has studied the lyrics of "Won't Get Fooled Again." nytimes.com/2013/05/06/opi…
— James Taranto (@jamestaranto) May 6, 2013

Wednesday, April 24, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 4/24/13: Hezbollah On The Prowl For Passports And Funding For Terrorism

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection


2) Getting around with Hezbollah

Last month the National Post reported Hezbollah deliberately seeks Canadians because of internationally accepted passports: senior CSIS official:
The terrorist group Hezbollah has been seeking operatives with Canadian passports, a senior intelligence official told MPs reviewing a bill Thursday that could strip terrorists of their citizenship. Appearing before the Standing Committee on Citizenship and Immigration, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service official said Canadian passport holders were being actively sought by terrorist groups. ... The RCMP is also investigating allegations a Lebanese-Canadian Hezbollah member was behind last July’s bombing of a bus full of Israeli tourists at Sarafovo airport on the Black Sea coast. The suspect, who now lives in Lebanon, had used his Canadian passport to travel to Bulgaria.

Monday, April 15, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 4/15/13: Some In The Media Are Getting Wise To J Street

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection


1) Bursting the balloon

When I saw the following headline at the Baltimore Jewish Times I was worried, " J Street Carved Out A Place In The U.S.-Israel Advocacy." The article, written by managing editor, Maayan Jaffe starts by faithfully recounting all of J-Streets claims. But, there's more to the title, that suggests that this isn't going to be another J-Street whitewash: "Israelis say Policies Don’t Jibe."

Jaffe first looks at J-Street's math and observes:

Wednesday, April 10, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 4/10/2013: Arab Spring A Disaster For US in Egypt and Syria

by David Gerstman, contributing blogger at Legal Insurrection

1) Egyptian plagues

Last week Zvi Mazel wrote in the Jerusalem Post (h/t Leslie Eastman)
In a remarkable and enduring show of unity, non-Islamic opposition parties under the banner of the National Salvation Front are boycotting the regime until their demands – canceling the Islamic constitution and setting up a consensus government until new elections are held – are met. 
The Muslim Brotherhood who had won a sweeping victory in the first free parliamentary elections and got their candidate elected president have bitterly disappointed the people who had put their faith in them.

Sunday, March 17, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 03/17/2013: Thomas Friedman Strikes (Out) Again!

From David Gerstman:

1) When elephants crash land

Recently, I brought up an example of how Professor Barry Rubin handled a mistake. First he admitted it. Then he explained the forces involved. His behavior showed a few things.
  1. He is serious about what he has written.
  2. He respects his audience's intelligence.

Neither of these qualities can be attributed to Thomas Friedman. 

A few weeks ago, Friedman wrote a column in which he faulted the Muslim Brotherhood for failing to govern Egypt effectively. Nowhere, in the essay does Friedman acknowledge that he had misunderstood the revolution in Egypt from the start. 

Wednesday, March 13, 2013

Mideast Media Sampler 3/13/13: Reporting On Israel Means Never Having To Say You're Sorry

From David Gerstman:

1) Being a reporter means never having to say you're sorry

The New York Times has reported on the UN report that raised doubts about the death of Omar Masharawi.

Isabel Kershner wrote U.N. Ties Gaza Baby’s Death to Palestinians:
Paul Danahar, the BBC Middle East bureau chief, wrote on his Twitter account that an Israeli shell had come through the roof of the small Gaza home. Mr. Danahar visited his grieving colleague there on Nov. 15 and posted a photograph of a roundish hole in the roof of a burned-out room. 
But a March 6 report by the Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights on the eight-day conflict, which ended with a cease-fire, stated that three people in the home — Omar, a woman and an 18-year-old youth — were most likely the victims of “what appeared to be a Palestinian rocket that fell short of Israel.” 
The circumstances of those deaths are likely to remain in dispute. Israel’s military has not determined whether it hit the house or not, saying it does not have clear information about what happened. The BBC has reported that privately, military officials told journalists at the time that Israel had aimed at a militant who was hiding in the building.
There are a few things here.

Friday, January 11, 2013

The Middle East Sampler 1/11/13: New York Times Criticizes Arabs!?

From +David Gerstman:

1) Shocker: The New York Times criticizes the Arabs

In an editorial, Financial crisis in the West Bank, the editors of the New York Times assert:
In the recent interview Mr. Fayyad put most of the blame for the authority’s financial distress on Arab donors who are “not fulfilling their pledge of support” made in Arab League resolutions to make up the money Israel is withholding. This should come as little surprise. Arab leaders have often promised political and economic support for the Palestinians and failed to deliver. Arab foreign ministers are expected to meet Sunday in Cairo to discuss Palestinian issues, including the promised aid. They should affirm their commitment to assist the Palestinian Authority and get the funds flowing.
And if the Arab world cared as much about the Palestinian as the New York Times purports to, maybe those foreign ministers would commit to meeting their pledges. But this is a longstanding issue as this article from 2008 shows, I hardly think that a New York Times editorial will change the situation.

While it's a positive development that the New York Times faulted the Arab world (however futilely),  unfortunately, there were five other paragraphs to the editorial.

Thursday, December 27, 2012

The Middle East Media Sampler 12/27/12: Telling Friedman and His Cheerleaders Can't Take Truth About Israel

From +David Gerstman :

1) "You can't handle the truth"

Credit: Wiki Commons
Yesterday's obnoxious and offensive op-ed by Thomas Friedman, Give Chuck a Chance had the following sentence (that a number of his Twitter fans promoted):
The only thing standing between Israel and national suicide any more is America and its willingness to tell Israel the truth.
What's the truth?

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

The Middle East Media Sampler 12/26/2012: Anti-Israel Activists Support Hagel Because He's Good For Israel?

From +David Gerstman:

1) Is Chuck roast?

Credit: Wiki Commons
Thomas Friedman joins Steven Walt in supporting the nomination of former Senator Chuck Hagel to be Secretary of Defense. (In Twitter, Friedman's view is supported by the likes of David RothkopfRobert Wright and Trita Parsi. We have the spectacle of anti-Israel activists endorsing Friedman's columns because he argues that Hagel would be good for Israel.) In Give Chuck a chance, Friedman writes:

Monday, December 24, 2012

The Middle East Media Sampler 12/24/2012: Media Joins Arabs In Denigrating Israel's Successful UN Resolution

From DG:

Israel wins at the UN, no one notices
"If Algeria introduced a resolution declaring that the earth was flat and that Israel had flattened it, it would pass by a vote of 164 to 13 with 26 abstentions."
Abba Eban (h/t Elder of Ziyon)
I went over to the sargent, said, "Sargeant, you got a lot a damn gall to ask me if I've rehabilitated myself, I mean, I mean, I mean that just, I'm sittin' here on the bench, I mean I'm sittin here on the Group W bench 'cause you want to know if I'm moral enough join the army, burn women,kids, houses and villages after bein' a litterbug."
Arlo Guthrie - Alice's Restaurant

Last week Israel won a victory at the UN. You probably didn't read about it in any newspaper. Many news organizations believe that the only news about Israel worth reporting is news that shows that Israel is isolated. So here's the notification at one of Israel's Facebook pages: