Monday, December 24, 2007

Why Blame Hamas When You Have Israel: Oxfam Vs World Bank

From a Letter to the Editor of The Times
Sir, Your report, (“Israeli sanctions ‘will ruin plans to rebuild Palestinian economy’ ”, Dec 17) refers to reports from OxfamWorld Bank> and the Red Cross to support the claim that Israeli restrictions on Gaza are the primary impediment to improving conditions. Yet the difference between the Oxfam press release and the details of the World Bank report are startling.

The World Bank stated that “any effort at economic recovery and development must address the impacts of the current closure regime and the aftermath of the illegal takeover of Gaza” by Hamas; and that Israel, the PA and donors are working to “shield the Strip’s 1.4 million people from the impacts of the current political stalemate”. [see here]

In contrast, Oxfam ignores the role of Hamas and calls on donors to “ensure that restrictions on aid are not being used as a weapon against Palestinian civilians”. Oxfam also accuses Israel of “wrecking” projects and claims that work on the Beit Lahia sewage lake has “stalled . . . putting thousands of Palestinians at risk”, but the World Bank is able to report just three days later that “as a result of coordination with Israel . . . the work is expected to be completed by March”. [See: For aid to be effective, donors need to insist Israel changes its policies towards occupied Palestinian Territories]

For NGOs to play a full part in the debate, they must do their research and properly consider the context.

Legacy Heritage Fellow, NGO Monitor, Jerusalem [Emphasis added]
Technorati Tag: and and and .

No comments: